Saturday, June 21, 2008

Cops Beat Transexual Woman

Her name is Duanna Johnson, and she is yet another victim of police brutality.  Memphis police were caught on tape brutally assaulting her. What was it about her that triggered such a brutal reaction? Duanna operates with many factors of social stigmatization, she is a prostitute, black, and transexual, these aforementioned categories work to create Duanna as other, and less than in our society.  Even the news report that detailed the assault continually referred to her as a transexual, and a prostitute as though her gender identity, and occupation were the only defining characteristics of her person.  To the world at large women like Duanna are perceived as a threat because they blur our binary understanding of gender. Masculinity has much invested in maintaining strict gender roles.

The police officers in question allegedly referred to her as a he/she.  For patriarchy to remain in its position of power, it is necessary to silence voices that dispute the singularity of gender identification. By disavowing traditional patriarchal masculinity, and asserting an identity of her own choosing Duannas body became the symbol upon which male aggression attempted to stake its claim on the ability to transcend the limits of social construction. If masculinity were no longer hegemonic, it would disturb the current power structure that we now live under. Her beating ultimately was a punishment for her betrayal.

Why is this a womanist issue?  Duanna identifies as female and she is black, but beyond that the larger implications involve social justice. Regardless of race, class or gender no person deserves to beaten.  We must begin to hold our social institutions accountable when they violate our human rights. We must hold our so-called black leadership accountable when they do not speak out against issues like this.  Were this the case of a black man being beaten by white police officers, Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson would already have organized some kind of protest, or made a statement vilifying these officers for their behavior.  But Duanna is a pariah to these men, as though somehow her gender identification has stripped her, of her black identity. The black male patriarchy though negotiating race is equally invested in retaining male privilege, and power. To claim Duanna as one of ours, would threaten our understanding of race and gender.  Historically the black community has silenced people that are gay, trans or bi, as if by disavowing membership we can claim that these communities are not a part of our diversification. What our leaders fail to realize is that in diversification, there is power.  When we accept those amongst us, who society has chosen to cast asunder we not only strength our selves as a people, we give legitimacy to the claim that all we seek is equality.  You cannot stand for equality, and turn your back on injustice because the victim challenges your idea of normalcy. Duanna represents one of the most vulnerable members of our society, and if we cannot in good conscience recognize the need to protect her, who then is worthy to be sheltered from the storm of male patriarchal violence that has run amok in our society.


Ebony Intuition said...

I just viewed the video. Not only should the cop be fired or suspended the nurse should also be fired because she completely ignored the victim and attended to the news of the suspect (the cop)..

No one is safe in this society and this video proves it..

Anonymous said...

Unfortunately this situation is not unbelieveable in this society but the victim should not only get a public appology for being treated like some sort of animal but should be heavily compensated for the police departments and nurse's hurrendous crimes.

LynnAlexander said...

You have such a clear way of describing things as they are, and I agree wholeheartedly about this post.

I think there needs to be more recourse for discrimination and bias, and more protection against ALL kinds of hate crimes, not just the ones in our "comfort zones". This is disgusting and very sad. We can do much better. All of us, from high profile leaders on down.

Anonymous said...

I'm curious to find out what blog system you have been using? I'm expеriencing ѕοme ѕmall ѕeсurity issueѕ wіth mу latest ωebsitе anԁ I
ωοulԁ lіkе to fіnd something morе ѕеcuгe.
Dο you have any recommenԁationѕ?

Also viѕit mу web-site ::
Also see my web site > link building

Anonymous said...

Nice reѕpond in rеturn οf thіs querу with solid arguments аnԁ tellіng all about thаt.

my wеbѕite - Payday Loans

Anonymous said...

Hola! I was interested to know if setting up a weblog such your own: http:
// is tough to do for unskilled people?
I have been hoping to set up my own website for a while now but have been turned
off mainly because I've always believed it demanded tons of work. What do you think? Kudos

Feel free to surf to my blog post :: wisconsin auto insurance

Anonymous said...

Hey. I was thinking about adding a hyperlink back to your site since both
of our sites are based mostly around the same topic. Would you prefer I link to you using your site address: or website
title: Blogger: Womanist Musings. Please make sure to let
me know at your earliest convenience. Kudos

My blog: Suggested Web site